Murphy's
Haystacks

Inselburg - German for insel/island,
berg/mountain

Introduction

Murphy’s Haystacks is an inselburg (German for insel/island, berg/mountain) formation located on the Eyre Peninsula in South Australia, 39 kilometres south of Streaky Bay. The site can be accessed by travelling down Flinder’s Highway and turning onto the Calca – Point Labatt Road. This area is situated on a privately owned sheep-station and farm, owned by Denis Cash, grandson of the original owner Denis Murphy. The land has been owned by the family since 1889. It is believed the site obtained its name when a agricultural expert was travelling past the area by train. He commented that “the farmer must have harrowed his land to produce such an impressive abundance of hay”, thinking the rock formations where bales of hay. The name Murphy’s Haystacks then became the local place name.

Cost

Visitors are welcome to visit the site and are asked to pay at the honesty box nearby. $2 for single entry, $5 for family, all going towards maintaining the local amenities. Picnic tables and toilets are also available.

Geology

The rock that makes up Murphy’s Haystacks is a part of a larger mass, mainly comprising of Hiltaba Granite. This material has been dated back to of 1400-1500 million years ago, however, the current landmasses above are more recent and are at least 33,600 years old. Today at least 7-10 kilometres has been eroded away, showing the pink hue of the Hiltaba Granite that was once covered by limestone and sedimentary rock. The flared shape that resembles haystacks was created from weathering and the presence of water along fractures, that eroded the rock from below the surface soil due to a collection of moisture. As the soil level lowered in time, the moisture beneath lower and eroded the rock in a concave shape.

Age and Origin

The granite is the Hiltaba Granite and is part of a large mass that underlies much of the northwest Eyre Peninsula, the southwestern Gawler Ranges and adjacent areas (hence its name, from Hiltaba Station, in the southwestern Gawler Ranges). The rock is pink and coarsely equigranular with crystals of grey glassy quartz and pink feldspar prominent. This granite was emplaced deep in the earth’s -crust, probably some  km below the then surface, some-  millions of years ago. The age of the rock, which is vastly different from the age of the land forms now developed on it, has been physically determined in the following manner.

The Granite contains small amounts of minerals containing elements that are unstable, in that they lose particles constantly through time. Through this decomposition, which is called radioactivity, and is associated with the generation of heat, the original elements are changed into new substances. Thus uranium with an atomic weight of 238 gradually loses four particles of helium (atomic weight 8), changing in the process to omnium, radium, poloium and finally uranium – lead with an atomic weight of 206. The rate of decay or change is constant for all known conditions of pressure and temperature and can be measured. By measuring the proportional amounts of the original  elements to the end-product, the duration of time during which change or decay has taken place can be calculated. In the case of the West Coast granite it is the decay series strontium rubidium that has been used to determine the age of the minerals that include the strontium, and hence also the age of the rock that contains these minerals. An absolute age of 1400-1500 million years means that in terms of these of the geological calendar or time scale, the granites are of Proterozoic or Later Precambrian age.

The fact that the granites can now be seen at the land surface implies an enormous amount of erosion, for some 7-10 km of rock has been stripped away, causing the originally deep-seated granite to be exposed. The overlying rocks have been transported to and deposited in various basins and oceanic margins where they have accumulated in thick sequences and wedges of sedimentary rocks, as for instances beneath the continental shelf and slope off the west coast of Eyre Peninsula, and in the Polda Basin which contains some 1500 m of such sedimentary rocks.

But the landforms of Murphy’s Haystacks are much younger than the rocks of which they are formed though they are still old enough, in all conscience, in terms of the human life span. The various pillars and boulders of the Haystacks were already in existence in essentially their present form at least 33,600 years ago. At that time huge dunes of calcareous sand spread far inland from the coast, overwhelmed some of the lower hills of the region (such as Malijay Hill) and spread at least around the cases and into various crevices already etched into the granite rocks. Limestone derived from those dune sands now form a blanked over the hill, and is also preserved in open joints (as at H in Fig. 2, and P1. 2).

Fig 2 (A) morphological map of eastern area, (B) of weatern area

P1. 2 An hourglass form, a tall narrow pillar with flared slopes, in the eastern group. Fossiliferous lime-stone, more than 33,600 years old remains in an enlarged horizontal joint near the base.

The limestone at Murphy’s is fossiliferous rock but the rock has been dated by the carbon 14 method. The limestone at Murphy’s is more than 33,600 years old and some from the crest of Malijay is about 26,000 years old. Carbon 14 dating works as follows. All organic tissue contains carbon. Ordinary carbon has an atomic weight of 12, but carbon with an atomic weight of 14 forms as a result of the bombardment, by cosmic rays, of nitrogen in the upper atmosphere. This “heavy” carbon drifts down into the atmosphere and some is taken up by, and is incorporated in the tissues of, living plants and animals. There is a constant ratio of C14 and C12 in the atmosphere and also in any given type of organism (shell, wood, animal, human). The ratio of the two types of carbon in an organism remains constant, or in equilibrium, so long as the organism is alive, for th eloss of the electrons from the C14 already there and which causes the C14 to be reconverted to nitrogen, is balanced by the intake of new C14. When the organism dies, however, the situation changes radically, for although the decay of the C14 continues, the intake stops. This the proportion of C14 to C12 decreases. The rate of decay of C14 has been carefully measured, and is found to be constant, so providing a measure of the time that has elapsed since the death of the organism, and hopefully of the strata in which it is preserved in fossil form. Half the C14 disappears in about 5569+-30 years (a value known as the half life), in another 5568 years half of the remainder will have gone and so on.

The limestone formed on Oakfront Hill and in the creviced within rocks provides a rough measure of the time elapsed since its formation for it is derived from shells and other marine organisms shattered by the waves, picked up by the wind, and then drifted inland. There are many possible sources of error and in all likelihood the estimated age of more than 33,600 is too young; but it provides a minimum age for the features.

The major landforms present at Murphy’s Haystacks are pillars and boulders. Pillars are tall columns of rock that are in physical continuity with the granite of the hill (P1. 3; Fig. 3a). Boulders are more-or-less spherical masses that are detached from the underlying bedrock (P1. 4; Fig 3b). Both pillars and boulders are thought to result from the breakdown of the thick slabs or sheets of rock into which the granite is subdivided and which give Oakfront and other hills in the district their characteristics domed or convex-upward shape. The hills are subdivided by sets of fractures arranged in fan pattern when seen in section and that result in the formation of essentially cubic or quadrangular blocks (Fig. 3c). Such sheet structure is exposed in the flanks of nearby Malijay Hill, and better still on Ucontitchie Hill and Mt Wudinna where the granite is not masked by a cover of limestone. Sheets in course of disintegration can be seen on the northern side of little Wudinna Hill and at various other sites in Australia and overseas.

P1. 3 Haystacks with flared slopes a) in western group b-below) eastern; note shells of rock on crests.

P1. 4 Large boulders in western group with well developed flared slopes and tafoni separated by lichen covered ribs.

Fig. 3(a) pillar in physical continuity with, (b) boulder detached from, rock of hill. Fig. 3(c) Fan pattern of fracture.

Fig. 4 Development of flared slopes.

The pillars and boulders at Murphy’s Haystacks typically have side-walls that are smoothly concave: they are said to be flared. Such flared slopes result from weathering, by soil moisture, beneath the land surface, and especially along fractures (Fig. 4). Water penetrates along a fracture altering the rock with which it comes into contact. The mica and feldspar in particular are readily altered on contact with moisture. Fresh granite is difficult for water to infiltrate into, but the more the rock is altered the more permeable it becomes, and the more readily can more water enter the mass. Thus a zone of weathered rock is formed along a fracture. There is an abrupt transition between the altered rock and the still fresh rock. This boundary or junction is called the weathering front – the limit of significant weathering – and at several sites on Eyre Peninsula it can be seen to be concave-upward (P1. 5).

P1. 5 Yarwondutta Reservoir, near minnipa, showing exposed flared slopes on nearby slopes, and incipient flare – the weathering front – in the reservoir where the loose soil has been stripped away.

Because the near-surface soil tends to dry out at times, weathering is slower there than deeper down, where soil moisture is ever present. For this reason the weathered zone in fractures is wider at depth than near the surface, or put another way the weathering front becomes curved, and penetrates deeper into the host block a few metres below the surface than just below it or at great depths beyond the limit of soil moisture. Thus the weathering front is curved, and concaves with respect to the host block.

Now the main part of the block remains fresh and cohesive and so massive that it cannot be moved by rain and wash; but weathered granite (known as grus, from the German word for fine gravel) is washed away, so exposing the weathered front as a smooth concavity or flare, one on each side of the fracture. This two-stage process of subsurface weathering followed by erosion or removal of the weathered material takes place along all four of the fractures that delimit each of the blocks so that each pillar or boulder comes to be flared on all sides. Hence the haystack forms that are so well and so abundantly developed near the crest of Oakfront Hill. Penetration of water beyond the weathering front may be the cause of the flakes and shells (P1. 3) of rock that can be seen on some boulders and pillars, but this is uncertain – their origin is obscure. Where flared slopes have developed on comparatively small rocks, or, presumably, where there was more abundant water than elsewhere, the moisture in the fractures has eaten into the blocks to a marked degree and the boulder is now surrounded by a more-or-less narrow platform – a gently sloping rock fringe (P1. 6).

PI. 6. Narrow platform around base of pillar, and with steep basal cliff indicative of recent soil erosion.
In some instances the flared slope has advanced toward the centre of the block from all sides to such an extent that the platforms are wider than the remaining core (which has also been lowered by weathering), so that the residual looks like a boss standing above a shield (PI. 7). Carried to its logical extension such soil weathering will presumably cause the elimination of the boss leaving simply a flat or only broadly domed surface- a platform or a low whaleback (PI. 8). The only problem is to decide in the case of the platforms (like Z in Fig. 2) whether they are what remains after the boss has gone or whether what we see is the crest of a block that has only just been exposed? It is difficult to prove one way or another, though the fact that they stand, at the same sort of level as the bases of the nearby pillars suggest that they may be platforms from which bosses have been worn away.

PI. 7. Boss and shield in eastern group.

PI. 8. Rock platform, western group.

Some of the pillars and boulders are not only flared but have developed in their sides huge hollows known as tafoni (singular tafone), an Italian word meaning windows or perforations, and apt in the sense first that these hollows interrupt or breach the smooth outlines of the forms (PI. 9), and second that in extreme cases (as seen for instance on Granite Island near Victor Harbour, and on Mt Wudinna) a talon can develop to such an extent that the hollow breaches the outer shell so that a window or opening is formed- a site much favoured by photographers who record companions with just their heads sticking out from the rock! There is considerable argument still about how tiffany form; they were first described from Corsica about a century ago and the argument has gone o unabated ever since. But it is clear that since they commonly form alongside flared slopes (and not only at Murphy’s but at Ayers Rock and other places also) the two have a common origin in subsurface weathering: tiffany may develop where the moisture attack is especially effective. Second it is obvious that the outer skin of the granite, that which forms the projecting lips or visors, is somehow more resistant than the rest of the rock. It may be that a slight accumulation of iron and silica, formed either at the weathering front beneath the soil surface, or concentrated by the hyphae (roots) of lichens for instance (see projecting ribs in the tafone on block (Fig. 2) are covered by lichens – PI. 4). The most difficult problem connected with the tafoni however concerns how and why the inside walls of the tiffany have been and still are being worn back. The rock there is loose and fragmented, and can be loosened at the merest touch at some sites (e.g. at Ucontitchie Hill where the rock is breaking down in layer upon layer of thin flakes). Some workers have suggested that the crystallisation of halite (common salt) and gypsum, either blown in from the sea or from salt lakes, or produced by the weathering of certain minerals within the granite, could produce enough pressure to rupture the rock. But it is fair comment that this problem remains unsolved.

PI. 9. Large tafone with prominent overhanging visor, eastern group

At least one other feature seen at Murphy’s Haystacks is due to moisture attack at the weathering front. It will be noticed that the lower few centimeters (about a foot) of the sidewalls of many of the pillars has a rough surface in comparison with the smooth higher surface (PI. 10). Close examination shows that this roughness is due to quartz crystals (glassy or grey looking) standing out in relief, and this is because the feldspar and mica that was originally between the quartz have been rotted by water, and when the weathered rock was stripped away the tiny spaces previously occupied by the feldspar and mica are left empty. This feature is called ‘pitting’ and it provides a measure of how much the plain surface has been lowered recently (in this case, probably since the clearance of trees from the hill by Europeans and the erosion of the topsoil), the same erosion that caused the solid calcite later to be exposed over wide areas on the hill). Similar soil erosion is implied by the steep basal slopes of some pillars (PI. 6).

PI. 10. Pitting at base of rock, western group

Other features worthy of note are the vertical grooves (called Rille or Karren) which are due to water trickling down steep sidewalls- even overhanging faces- and gradually weathering and eroding shallow grooves (at G and Y, Fig. 2; PI. 11). There are good examples in both the eastern and western groups at Murphy’s. There is a complication which is well illustrated at Yarwondutta Rock, near Minnipa. There on one of the northern flared slopes there are grooves that now stand out as a ribs and it is suggested that the trickles initially erode a groove, but that this becomes a preferred site for lichen growth. The lichen protects the surface (as at X in the western group of Murphy’s – see Fig. 2) and it is the adjacent areas that are next weathered and eroded leaving the original grooves higher and looking like ribs (PI. 12). The same sort of thing can be seen on the northern slope of the Dinosaur (Lizard Rock) near Mt Wudinna.

PI. 11. Rille or vertical grooves on the inside wall of a tafone in the eastern group

PI. 12. These old grooves on the slopes of Yarwondutta Rock, have been protected by black algae carried there by run-off, so that they now stand out as ribs- this is called relief inversion

Some linear depressions, grooves and gutters are due to weathering along fractures or other weaknesses in the rock, and there are many examples. One on the crest of (Fig. 2)in the western group is largely developed along a vein of fine grained granite rock (PI. 13). Also on this crest is a shallow depression known as a rock basin or gnamma, again the result of water rotting the rock (PI. 14).

PI. 13. Gutter developed along a vein on top of a large pillar in the western group

PI. 14. Rock basin or gnamma on the same rock

Review of development. 1. Emplacement of mass of granite at depth of 7-10 km about 1400-1500 millions of years ago. 2. Deep erosion and removal of rocks that formerly cover the granite, which has been stressed resulting in the development of sheet structure as the mass came to be close to the land surface 3. In pre-Pleistocene times, i.e. more than 2 millions of years ago, the upper shell was broken down into cubic or quadrangular blocks, and flared slopes were developed on the sides of the blocks. Because the crystal area was in tension, the blocks there were weathered quickly. Likewise those on lower slopes were rotted rapidly and also eroded, so that only the blocks on upper slopes persisted. 4. During glacial periods of low sealable during the Pleistocene huge coastal dunes, consisting mainly of calcium carbonate developed and spread inland, covering many nearby hills and certainly lapping around the bases of the haystacks. 5. In recent times a soil developed on the lime sand and since European settlement the topsoil has been eroded (to a depth of about 25cm) exposing the solid lime B horizon that we see on the hill crest and slopes, and above which the Haystacks stand.